2023.03.23

Digital Rights Archive Newsletter - Fourth edition

One of the most fascinating things about the current explosion of interest in artificial intelligence – the term that’s been adopted to describe any number of automated and generative digital processes, despite long-standing warnings that it’s as much a marketing term as anything else – is the complex sense of resignation that seems to have accompanied it. Despite pervasive worries about its effect on the foundations of our education system, the incorporation of falsehood-spewing chatbots into search, and much else besides, the conventional wisdom seems to be that it might be a net negative for society, but we’re just going to have to figure out how to live with it. 

The future, in short, is what we make of it. Our choices could leave us worse off, as Joanna Mazur and Renata Włoch believe may be happening with the EU’s Artificial Intelligence Act, which they argue “does not include solutions that would allow the societal actors to enforce their rights concerning artificial intelligence.” Or, also in Europe, whether the potential adoption of social credit initiatives may lead to invasive, rights-harming surveillance, as Laurent Mucchielli suggests.

But we can also make better choices. In a very creative article that breathes new life into the case study method (those interested in social science methodologies will find this article illuminating for this alone), Britt S. Paris, Corinne Cath and Sarah Myers West highlight how our ideas about internet infrastructure and governance shape what we think of as possible and desirable in this area. In doing so, they point to a way forward that emphasizes what they call “cooperativity, not connectivity,” and requires us to ask hard questions “about who is served by information and communication infrastructures, and how.”

Overcoming this sense of the inevitable, in internet governance or artificial intelligence, is difficult because it requires imagining a different future than the one currently offered for sale from the big players. We’re fortunate that people like Paris, Cath and West, and the other thinkers featured here, are helping to imagine the road maps to a more humane future.

- Blayne Haggart

Journalism
Article
Article
Article
Video
Article
Article
Journalism
Document
Journalism